BREAKING: Tigray war mortality: half a million people? Professor Jan Nyssen, Ghent University
Source: Martin Plaut
March 13, 2022
We often get questions on numbers of deaths due to this war. It is very difficult to know due to near-absence of communication as well as the blackmailing of NGOs who have a partial view of the situation, but do not speak out for fear of being banned from working in Ethiopia.
With the assistance of citizen scientist Tim Vanden Bempt, we made the assessment that so far there are between 150,000 and 200,000 starvation deaths, 50,000 to 100,000 victims of direct killings, and more than 100,000 additional deaths due to lack of health care.
The starvation deaths are based on the figures of the IPC – Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (400,000 people in famine, May/June 2021) and USAID (900,000 in famine, June 2021). The situation is probably much more extreme now than it was then, but humanitarian aid during the summer months and the autumn harvests have apparently provided a welcome respite. The WFP was able to do a fairly extensive study that is downright terrifying. The harvest would be exhausted by April and if the humanitarian blockade remains, up to 50% of the population could be left without access to food.
The number of deaths due to lack of health care is based on the excess mortality that it generates. In normal circumstances, an average of 6 people per 1000 inhabitants die in Ethiopia in a year, according to according to an instructive curveprepared by the World Bank.
During the conflict months of November 2020 to June 2021, we estimated that there were 20 deaths per 1000 people and starting with the total blockade 32 per 1000. Twenty out of 1000 was the rate of health-related deaths in 1984-85, before the improvements in the Ethiopian health system. According to Dr. Tony Magaña, this number has risen to 32 deaths per 1,000 since the blockade started. The excess mortality was then calculated, not on the entire population but on the total of 3.9 million people in need of medical care according to OCHA.
Of the number of soldiers killed we have no idea. The tallied number of civilian direct casualties is at least 10,000. Probably they amount to 50,000 – 100,000, as there are many reports of civilian corpses “seen along the way when fleeing”, without mentioning location, date, numbers,…
There is a possible partial overlap between the categories. Yet, in the worst-case scenario there would be half a million civilian deaths.
The fact that the UN was not allowed to transport documentation material (USB drives, phones, cameras, etc.) from and to Tigray for a very long time (and even now), has meant that the situation in Tigray is very poorly documented. Journalists who could report about the situation on the ground are not allowed to travel to Tigray.
Farmers are really nearing the margin. Individual accounts witness that in many parts of Tigray people have run out of food, sold their valuables, and now abandon their homes in search of food. There is no clear view of where they go. In normal times people would go to urban areas, which is not possible these days as the situation is even worse in urban areas. Sadly, human trafficking including to Addis Ababa, is also emerging as a business. The desperation is to the level that people have started crossing the borders to Amhara region in search of food for survival. That sounds like the toughest decision to make, as the Amhara region is considered a stronghold for interests conflicting those of the Tigrayan people.
ACAPS (www.acaps.org) has published a very detailed thematic report: Tigray Region: Drivers of Food Insecurity and Outlook (1 March 2022). If not yet received, it is available upon request.
More information on the same topic:
- OCHA, 10 March 2022: Humanitarian partners continue to reduce their operations in Tigray due to lack of supplies, fuel, and cash.
- Catholic News Service, 3 March 2022: New report highlights Tigray atrocities, says Ethiopia could face famine
- The Guardian, 2 March 2022: Patients dying as conflict prevents supplies reaching Tigray hospitals
- OCHA: Ethiopia – Northern Ethiopia Humanitarian Update Situation Report, 17 February 2022
- WHO, 14 February 2022: Lack of fuel prevents distribution of critically-needed medical supplies in Tigray region
We received this overview of the situation in the Mekelle-Hagere Selam area from people working on the betterment of the humanitarian situation, as well as a historical document on the battle for Hagere Selam.
Right now, the condition is as follows:
- No schooling. All the children would like to be trained, but most of the school materials are destroyed. Every child thinks about the drone and airstrike. They never feel safe.
- More than 90% of health care facilities are destroyed.
- Families are in disarray. No salary for the last eight months. Everybody is looking for aid but can’t get it. They are losing their children due to hunger and starvation. They are unable to save their families.
- No medicine. Due to lack of medicine thousands of people are dying. The death rate is extremely high.
- No communication. Instead of calling and messaging through phone, we go back to the old way of communication. We write a letter and ask someone to take it. Most of the time it gets lost somewhere and sometimes it arrives very late.
- No bank. Even if people have money in their account, they are not able to withdraw because there is lack of cash in the bank – any bank communication is blocked and the cash has been looted by Ethiopian troops, when withdrawing from Mekelle, back in June 2021.
- No electricity. The main power line was from Addis Ababa and they cut it off. After they cut it, the Tigray electric power was connected to Tekeze Hydropower. The substation was then hit by drone strike. Again it was repaired. Then the main station in Mekelle was hit. Again they repaired it and so on. Very tiresome.
- No fuel. Transportation costs have increased tremendously.
- Farmers did not harvest as usual. Because the farmlands were not properly ploughed on time and lacked fertilizer.
- Even if you have cash at hand things are quite expensive to buy.
- Every week there is high inflation. For example early February, the EthioTrees project bought food for the communities. We paid 2800 birr for one quintal (100 kg) of wheat and 4300 birr for 1 quintal of flour but early Marchit is 3700 birr and 5200 birr for the same amount.
- See a tabulated view of price increases: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6344845
Then, in one of our earlier circular letters we informed the outside world about the Hagere Selam massacre; recently Tigrai TV has been to the place and made this report: https://twitter.com/GuaGuaTigray/status/1469063607023554564
A video has also emerged, showing the strong cooperation between Ethiopian and Eritrean armies in the battle against the Tigray Defence Forces, on the road between Mekelle and Hagere Selam, back in late 2020.
The introduction to the video is in Tigrinya language, as it was broadcast by an Eritrean opposition YouTube channel. They mention that the film looks professionally prepared, not just filmed by an individual with a smartphone. The film was on a video cassette found near a dead soldier in the battle for Lalibela.
In the talk between the Ethiopian and Eritrean commanders, the target of the attack is mentioned several times: Hagere Selam mountain pass, which they eventually conquered.
Amongst the commanders that are extensively filmed, there are most probably also the Ethiopian and Eritrean defence personnel responsible for the massacre in Hagere Selam and surroundings in December 2020, and destruction of the town, as well as massacres in the wider Ala’isa-Addilal-May Leiba area. One Eritrean commander is identified as Brig-Gen. Haddish Ephrem (who belongs to the Eritrean president Isayas Afewerki’s inner circle) and from the Ethiopian side Major-Gen. Zewdu Belay.
More information on the same topic:
- Reuters, 2 March 2022: UN rights forum picks ex-ICC prosecutor to lead Ethiopia abuses investigation
- Meridiano42, 7 March 2022: Bensouda to head UN commission for war crimes and crimes against humanity in Ethiopia
- UNHRC, 2 March 2022: President of Human Rights Council appoints members of investigative body in Ethiopia
- NewsCentralTV, Nigeria, 4 March 2022. Atrocities in Ethiopia and the appointment of UN investigators (interviews of Hailu Kebede, Salsay Weyane Tigray party & Dr David Matsanga, African Affairs analyst)
- Tghat, 19 February 2022: An Ethiopian Soldier from UN Interim Security Force for Abyei (UNISFA) to Mahbere Dego Massacre
The ongoing genocidal war in Tigray has subjected over 100,000 women and girls to systematic rape and sexual violence. Tseday, 17, told Amnesty International that she was abducted by eight Eritrean soldiers in Zebangedena and held captive for two weeks. She said: “They took me to a rural area, in a field. There were many soldiers; I was raped by eight of them… Usually, they went out to guard the area in two shifts. When four of them went out, the rest stayed and raped me.” This is a story of tens of thousands of girls and women.
Survivors of rape and sexual violence are not getting necessary medical and other support due to the ongoing siege and de-facto humanitarian blockage.
“Kvinner for Kvinner i Tigray (KFK-Women to Women)”, a nonprofit organization based in Norway is currently fundraising to help women and girls survivors restore their lives. KFK is partnering with the Women’s Association of Tigray (WAT), an organization on the ground supporting survivors of sexual violence. WAT plans to organize and provide a training to 205 young women volunteers who will help the survivors in different ways.
Crowdfunding in Norwegian: https://www.spleis.no/project/214602
Bank transfers: KVINNER FOR KVINNER, bank account number 1506 74 23000, IBAN NO0212345678910
More information on the same topic:
- Addis Standard, 8 March 2022: Fifteen women’s organizations call on UN for vital services to sexual violence survivors in Tigray
- Ephrem Berhe, Paltiel, O., Hailemariam Gebrearegay, Hiluf Ebuy, Mengistu Hagazi, Hale Teka, Afework Mulugeta, 2022. Ethiopia’s Tigray dialysis service cut due to dwindling supplies amid war. Kidney International Reports, in press.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ekir.2022.02.024
- Favara M, Hittmeyer A, Porter C, Singhal S, Tassew Woldehanna, 2022. Young people, mental health, and civil conflict: Preliminary findings from Ethiopia’s Tigray region. Psychiatry Research Communications:100025.
- Berhanu Gebremedhin et al., 2022. In Tigray Even Research Institutions Are Not Spared: The Plight of Tigray Agricultural Research Institute
- Awet T. Weldemichael, Yibeyin Hagos Yohannes, Meron Estefanos, 2022. Between a Rock and a Hard Place – Eritrean Refugees in Tigray and the Ethiopian Civil War. An IPRA report.
The international community has rapidly taken a strong stance in opposing Ukraine’s invasion. Both Ukraine and Tigray are victims of war crimes committed by governments. We hope now that the international community will also stand up for the7 million Tigrayans besieged by the Ethiopian and Eritrean armies.
We have noticed how Russian scientists immediately reacted against the war on Ukraine:https://www.researchgate.net/post/Letter_of_Russian_Scientists
Unfortunately, we have not seen a similar move by Ethiopian scientists when the war on Tigray was launched. Ethiopian academic institutions rather actively participated in the war. See this database: the Ethiopian public universities during the Tigray war.
Also in Russia, universities are supporting Putin’s war.
In a reaction, on 10 March, the rector of Ghent University (Belgium) mentions that, “Institutional cooperation with Russian universities that support the invasion in Ukraine, and student exchange or cooperation between academics that takes place within that framework, is no longer possible.” Let us hope that universities worldwide take a similar stand, also in relation toEthiopian universities actively supporting the war on Tigray.
More information on the same topic:
- Meridiano 42, 7 March 2022: Eritrea is one of only five countries to openly side with Russia in the UN vote. Risk of further isolation.
- NPR, 4 March 2022: Not every war gets the same coverage as Russia’s invasion — and that has consequences
- Maher Mezahi: Viewpoint on Ukraine: Why African wars get different treatment (BBC)
- Richard Reid: Eritrea is involved in Tigray to boost its stature. Why the strategy could backfire
- RTS, 23 January 2022. Interview of Charlotte Touati: Ethiopie : la foi dʹun pouvoir génocidaire [in French] – Ethiopia: the religion of a genocidal power (podcast)
- Washington Post, 12 March 2022: In Ethiopia, a video of civilians burned alive sparks anger – see also this Twitter thread by journalist Zecharias Zelalem https://twitter.com/ZekuZelalem/status/1502430564581888002
- CNN, 31 January 2022: Ethiopian Airlines employees are fleeing the country by hiding in the planes they work on
- Brussels Times, 2 February 2022: Belgium grants asylum to Ethiopian plane stowaways
- AlJazeera, 25 February 2022. ‘Ethnic cleansing’: Ethiopian allies accused of Abala massacre
- GlobeNewsNet, 8 March 2022: More Than 300 Civilians Killed in Three Months of Ethiopia Airstrikes: UN
- The Guardian, 20 February 2022: Facebook ‘lets vigilantes in Ethiopia incite ethnic killing’https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/feb/20/facebook-lets-vigilantes-in-ethiopia-incite-ethnic-killing
- Reporter, 20 February 2022: ‹‹ወደፊት በትግራይ እንዲህ ያለ ኃላፊነት የሚቀበል ሰው አለ ብዬ አላምንም›› ሙሉ ነጋ(ዶ/ር)፣ የቀድሞ የትግራይ ክልል ጊዜያዊ አስተዳደር ዋና ሥራ አስፈጻሚ [in Amharic] – ‘I don’t believe anyone will accept such responsibility in Tigray in the future’, Mulu Nega (Dr.), former chief executive of the Temporary Administration of the Tigray Region. In this interview, Mulu Nega states among others:
- During the Tigray war, we had intense communications with Eritrean generals, including with general Filipos, who was stationed in Wukro
- It is not true that the Ethiopian government spent 100 Billion birr to rebuild Tigray in the first half of 2021, like PM Abiy claims
- The Tigray war was not law enforcement, but power struggle
- Abiy Ahmed promised several times that the Amhara and Eritrean troops would leave Western Tigray but this has not happened
- The Eritrean army blocked the movement of humanitarian aid inside Tigray
- Rashid Abdi: No doubt about the military alliance between three countries – Ethiopia, Eritrea and Somalia
- John Young: Tigray democracy for a post-war democratic Tigray
- Gebrehiwot Hadush: For lasting peace, TPLF’s monopolization of power in Tigray must end (Ethiopia Insight)
- Dirk Van Merode, Stijn Coenen: De zon gaat onder in Ethiopië [in Dutch]
- Jan Nyssen: Testimony at the Tigray demonstration in Brussels on 17 February 2022 (video)
- Mehari Taddele Maru: There Is a Path to Peace in Tigray (Foreign Policy)
Professor of Physical Geography
Department of Geography